Bank charges case reignited by new argument Go compare with our comparison table

Bank charges case reignited by new argument

17 December 2009 / by Andy Davies

Bank charges must be proved by banks to be fair, a new argument from MoneySavingExpert.com claims.

Following the verdict of Supreme Court last month to rule in favour of the banks regarding whether unauthorised overdraft charges should be assessed using fairness rules, MoneySavingExpert.com (MSE) has found a new argument to challenge the decision.

In light of the bank charges ruling, the consumer revenge website has obtained legal advice which it says now means the burden is on the banks to prove charges are fair rather than customers having to prove they are unfair.

In addition, MSE argues that as the Supreme Court ruled that bank charges are part of the price of an account, and since it is the FSA's responsibility to regulate bank accounts, MSE believes that the court's ruling could mean the FSA can now investigate the case directly, without the need for court.   

Commenting, Martin Lewis, creator of MoneySavingExpert.com said: "The host of new legal routes to challenge the fairness should give renewed hope to the millions of people waiting to get the money back that was unfairly taken from their accounts.

Calling on the Office of Fair Trading (OFT) for its support, he said: "The OFT has already provisionally said it thinks charges aren't fair, and having had legal advice, we believe there are substantial legal avenues available for it to challenge fairness. Therefore, it seems quite simple; the OFT cannot give up.

"Yet if the OFT refuses to live up to its name and fight for fairness then we and other consumer groups are looking to publish a fresh round of template letters - and possibly organising a group action."

But he said the cost of this "could run into millions" before warning that this could result in societies' poorest being "priced out of justice".

Supporting Martin Lewis' campaign, Liberal Democrat leader Nick Clegg, said: "Banks' must not be allowed off the hook after the astonishing court judgment last month - the fight must go on. The excessive fees imposed by banks are simply wrong and must be changed. There is a simple principle of fairness at stake that bank charges must be transparent and proportionate."

© Fair Investment Company Ltd

 

 AccountInterest (AER)Overdraft RateFunding Required*Fee pmFeaturesApply
5.00%**0.0%£0.00NilUp to £300 Cashback when you switch your current accountMore Info >
0.00%Daily fees on agreed overdrafts£0.00Nil£5 cashback every month you deposit £1,000. More Info >
Up to 3%19.30%£0.00NilEasy switching process. Earn up to 3% AER on balances of £3,000-£5,000 with Vantage. £10 overdrafts buffer and grace period.More Info >
0.0%19.30%£0.00 NilTelephone and Online Banking - Simply, free and easy to useMore Info >
0.0%18.30%£300.00£5pmBenefits include mobile phone insurance, cardholder protection and much more for £6.50 per month.More Info >
0.0%18.30%£300.00£15Benefits include Travel Insurance, mobile phone insurance, breakdown cover and much more for £15 per month.More Info >
0.0%17.90 %£500.00£12.95Could provide you with up to £500 of benefits & services a year. £6pm for first 3 months. ID theft and personal safety assistance. Text Banking. HSBC Advance Specialist 24/7 on hand.More Info >
0.0%19.90 %£500NilOverdraft, award-winning online banking, access to 4% savings accountMore Info >
0%19.89%£0.00NilA flexible current account for day-to-day banking. Overdraft (subject to eligibility) - extra breathing space for your finances. Over 18s only. More Info >
0.0%19.49%£100.00 £12.95For the third year running, the independent financial research company Defaqto gave Advantage Gold their 5 Star rating for product features, benefits and charges (February 2011).More Info >
£0.0019.24%£100.00£12.95Mobile phone insurance - includes iPhones; Green Flag car breakdown cover - even on your driveway; Annual world wide travel insurance - includes winter sports.More Info >
0%19.89%£0.00NilA flexible current account for day-to-day banking. Overdraft (subject to eligibility) - extra breathing space for your finances. Over 18s only. More Info >
0%18.9%£700 per monthNilPreferential rates on savings and loans. Free European travel insurance, discounts on home insurance. No monthly fee. (Pay in a minimum of £750 per month to get the benefits.)More Info >

*Some current accounts require customers to pay in a minimum amount each month.

**See Terms and Conditions